The Best Eyeshadow Bases, According To You - Beauty Bay Edited (2025)

By Catherine Donaldson | 15th December 2022

Are you finding your eyeshadow looks fade within a few hours? Then listen up! Whether you’re a beauty beginner or a makeup expert, an eyeshadow base is an essential in any makeup routine. This product can be used in many ways, from creating a cut crease and enhancing the pigment of shadows, to prepping and priming the lids for product, including the application of an eyeshadow base is key to ensuring looks last longer.

We all want to increase the longevity of our looks, but we also all want to make sure we get the right eyeshadow base for us. Well, we’ve saved you from all the searching by tracking down our customer’s (the true experts) reviews to create a list of the best eyeshadow bases we have available, according to you.

1. By BEAUTY BAY Eye Base

“A GOOD LITTLE PRIMER.”

This is a ‘concealer’ type of primer ie it has coverage. It’s easy to apply with the doe foot & works well with a number of different formulas. You can choose to use it wet ( as I do ) or powder it down first. For the price it’s good & comes in a range of skin tones plus pure white.

Nicky

“AWESOME”

I like it very much, it’s not greasy nor does it dry the skin. Performance 10/10.

Edaenia

“BEST PRIMER I’VE EVER USED”

This is hands down the best primer I’ve ever used! The first time using it I proceeded to load my brush up with eyeshadow powder as normal but soon realised I had far too much on the brush now. A little really goes a long way now with using this primer. It held my eyeshadow perfectly all day with no creasing

Joey

Haul it:

2. Urban Decay Eyeshadow Primer Potion

“HOLY GRAIL!”

I first tried this as it came in a set, I have really greasy skin and my eyeshadow always creased or separated on my eyelids within a couple of hours. This has honestly changed my life when it comes to make up! My eyeshadow stays in place all day and my eyelids stay matte, I’ve never tried another product that actually works like this!

Lipstickjunkie

“BEST EYESHADOW PRIMER USED”

Amazing. Doesn’t crease at all. Lasts through even 14+ hours, with oily skin. Holds pigment really well.

Imogen

“FANTASTIC”

Helps my eyeshadow stay on all day. Easy to use.

Ashleigh

Haul it:

3. Danessa Myricks Beauty Colorfix Invisible Eyeshadow Base

“TRULY AMAZED!”

Sooooo why is no one talking about this?! I decided to try this out on a whim because I love Danessa Myricks Beauty and have confidence in her products. This primer takes no exception – it does the job and truly is invisible. I’ve even taken to using it as an under eye primer and I’m so glad that I did – my concealer does not budge! Don’t go overboard and certainly don’t place into your eye creases – just dab on, let dry completely, and place your concealer on top. Set with a light powder and you’re golden!

JodieLynette

Haul it:

4. LH Cosmetics Till The End Eyeshadow Primer

“EYESHADOW PRIMER”

Amazing primer, last all day and night. A little expensive but really good product.

J_Plt

Haul it:

5. Sigma Beauty Eyeshadow Base Primer

“IT ACTUALLY WORKS!”

Best primer out there. Neutral colour and eyeshadow stays put all day without the greasy crease you can get from other products!

Kerry

“AMAZING PRODUCT”

I purchased this after seeing James Welsh uses this and I can totally see why. A couple of strokes and then I pat it in and it leaves a great base for colour and doesn’t crease but it also look totally fab on its own. It instantly became an essential must have!

Sarah

“LOVE IT!”

Lovely eyebase, makes eyeshadows go on pigmented and blend super nicely!

Eve_

Haul it:

6. MAC Cosmetics Pro Longwear Paint Pot

“DEFFO WORTH THE BUY!”

Such amazing coverage!

Aimee-Leigh England

“POWERFUL PRIMER OR PIGMENT”

I use the Pro Longwear Paint Pot in Painterly as a primer for powder eye shadow. It is a powerful primer! It holds the color – fresh and in place- all day. I could definitely wear it alone, as well, but as a primer it cannot be beat.

Catherine

“BRILLIANT AS AN EYE-BASE”

I love this product! I use it as a base and it looks as good after a hard day at work as when I put it on. Helps my make-up last all day. Highly recommended. (I use Soft Ochre. I have a medium neutral skin colour (not pink or yellow), blue eyes and dark lashes.)

Lharper17

Haul it:

7. Jason Wu Beauty We-Prime Eyeshadow Primer

“A FANTASTIC FIND, LOVE IT!”

Finally opened this to try, wow! It’s amazing, beautiful texture, goes on easily and creates a smooth base that makes eyeshadow perfect. I’ve rarely used eyeshadow primer but this is a game changer for me

Sarah

Haul it:

8. Milani Eyeshadow Primer

“REALLY ENJOYED IT”

Very effective product, eyeshadow stays on all day

Jane

“GREAT PRIMER”

I absolutely love this primer. I was always an Urban Decay fan, but this has taken over it. Great product.

Ginnykins

“VERY GOOD PRODUCT”

I never thought this primer would work on my oily eyelids but it did! My eyeshadow doesn’t crease or smudge for 12 hours. It’s a great product for it’s price!

Peach

Haul it:

9. NYX Professional Makeup HD Eyeshadow Base

“WILL NEVER USE ANOTHER EYE PRIMER”

NYX eyeshadow primers are the only ones I’ll ever use. I’ve tried enough to know there isn’t one better than this. Applies really smooth, dries quickly and holds my eyeshadow all day long, even though i have eyelids that crease easily.

Kimberley

“NOTHING TO SAY”

Perfect texture, perfect blending, perfect color, all great

Maklien

Haul it:

10. e.l.f. Cosmetics Shadow Lock Eyelid Primer

“VALUE FOR MONEY, NICE PRODUCT.”

Easy to use, nice colour match for my skin. Good value for money.

Robyn

Haul it:

11. Makeup Revolution Ultimate Eye Base Eye Primer

“AMAZING AS AN EYE PRIMER / CONCEALER”

Very thick formula makes for a great blank base for eyeshadows. Since it has such good coverge, I can also use this Makeup Revolution primer as a concealer for any difficult spots that need hiding.

Lucy 🙂

“A GOOD EYE BASE.”

A good base for eyeshadow. Lasts all day and is very affordable.

Chick

Haul it:

Shop Eyeshadow Bases

The Best Eyeshadow Bases, According To You - Beauty Bay Edited (2025)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Errol Quitzon

Last Updated:

Views: 6312

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (79 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Errol Quitzon

Birthday: 1993-04-02

Address: 70604 Haley Lane, Port Weldonside, TN 99233-0942

Phone: +9665282866296

Job: Product Retail Agent

Hobby: Computer programming, Horseback riding, Hooping, Dance, Ice skating, Backpacking, Rafting

Introduction: My name is Errol Quitzon, I am a fair, cute, fancy, clean, attractive, sparkling, kind person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.